Scotland: National Rural NetworkHaving checked out Norette's link to the BBC website on the subject of Poo Loos in the Cairngorms, I had to smile!
In the space of a few days I have discussed this sensitive topic amongst colleagues at meetings as diverse as Local Access Forums where the issue is serious and affects animal and human health. At the City Farms and Gardens and Allotments Conference many of us shared and discussed issues around the need for eco loos at allotments which were usually unserviced.
You know when you hear a word for the first time? It rolls about your brain repeating itself, then suddenly you hear other people using it again and again. Then you feel quite smug because . . . you now know what it means after you bothered to look it up and you now include it in your own vocabulary! Well, eco loos are a bit like that for me just now.
Since being introduced to the concept a few weeks ago, because it is one of our Forth Valley & Lomond LEADER projects, I now find myself asking unsuspecting people what they know about eco loos and "where can you find the best models, how did you get on with planning and SEPA etc"? You would be surprised at how many know so very little, but, like me, want to know more.
Whether you are shopping in Buchanan Street or walking up Ben Lomond the call of nature is common to all. Since the new access laws, it cannot be denied, that with an ever increasing number of folk concentrated on finite popular outdoor spaces, this can result in, what SEPA would describe as "point source pollution"!
Responsible dog owners know what to do, cats know what to do and so do dyed in the wool responsible access takers who always carry with them a little trowel.
We don't want to despoil or polute our beautiful landscape with public loos half way up Ben Lomond. However, given the increasing numbers of visitors now accessing and putting pressure on previously remote areas, perhaps we need a different approach. The kind of visitor we are now getting in such vast numbers to pressure points, is not likely to be persuaded to bring an emergency trowel with them never mind dig a hole, but an eco loo, they might just cope with.
Nor do we don't want to litter the landscape with the ubiquitous, male and female, pebble dash type edifices, so often suffered by otherwise attractive villages. I can, though, visualise little stone built, heather thatched, unisex, dunnies or eco loos nestling discreetly in corries and blending with their surroundings like the climber's bothies, although I know even these have been under threat from health and safety types! Circular cabins built with vertical logs which blend into and enhance the forests demonstrating that man can blend with nature in more ways than one!
That's the outside sorted then. What about the actual workings? Who out there knows a thing or two about sustainable, efficient eco loos that can get past Planning, SEPA and the likes? Please write in and share any expertise you have on eco loos.
Join the Network Now!
Eco Loo Report - Now available!
Forth Valley & Lomond LEADER LAG have recently completed a study into the Provision of Sustainable Toilets in Remote Rural Locations. The report takes a close look at the costs, practicalities and realities of installing and running remote toilets. It has sections on the various types of composting toilets currently on the market and also has a number of useful case studies which provide a glimpse into the real world of toilet management!
The report is available on the Forth Valley and Lomond LEADER website at www.fvl.org.uk . Because of its size it has been split into separate PDF files comprising of the Main Report and separate Case Studies. The report and case studies will also be available as one large PDF document.ketteridgea@stirling.gov.uk
For more information on the project contact Anne-Michelle Ketteridge at
We are grateful to Scottish Natural Heritage for funding towards this project.
Having portable toilet is
Having a portable toilet is important especially when it comes to camping.
Invitation to tender for eco loos study
Forth Valley and Lomond LEADER have issued an invitation to tender for A Study into the Provision of Sustainable Toilets in Remote Rural Locations. You can get more information here:
https://www.ruralgateway.org.uk/en/node/1571
Eco loos - a solution
Very interesting article and I loved the beautiful wooden loo in the argyll woods, it would be great to see more of those across Scotland!
Another good and portable solution is the BioToi which is popular with many festival goers, allotment holders, campers/caravanners, long distance drivers, IBS sufferers, walkers, foresters and other outdoors folks. It has a very sturdy plastic frame and uses compostable biodegradable bags which you use once and can then dispose of by digging a hole (away from watercourses!), in sewage plants, septic tanks or campsite sewage disposal units. They were developed to NATO specifications for the Norwegian Armed Forces and are very lightweight and portable.
They are available from www.campingloo.com and could be useful for communities as a stop-gap until planning permission is granted for a 'proper' composting loo!
Case Study from Community Woodlands Association
I've just found an interesting, illustrated case study on a log loo in Argyll on the Community Woodlands Association website. Here's the link: http://www.communitywoods.org/upld/The_Log_Loo.pdf There are contact details at the end of the case study.
Eco Loos
May I suggest that one contacts the Planning Service at Aberdeenshire Council in Stonehaven where they have experience of design and determinations of applications for eco loos.
There is one at the walks at Cambus O May on the A93, 3 miles east of Ballater
eco loos
If someone does come up with an eco loo design please trial it on Mull first because if you will pardon the expression, we are desperate! I have found that to attract the governments attention you have to suggest that there is a good photo opportunity in it first and then they show more interest, but sitting on an eco loo might not be a winner in this case.
Joking aside how about eco loos as a project for someone studying eco tourism or similar?
Global Dry Toilet Association
Just thought I'd have a little google search on the topic of eco loos and came across the website of the Global Dry Toilet Association in Finland! They've had a conference this year and you can get links to the presentations here:
http://www.drytoilet.org/dt2009/full.html
I thought the one from Finland called 'To dry or not to dry - People matter in scaling up dry sanitation' might be of interest.
Eco loos in Scotland and the Finland conference
I am working with the company 'Living Water Ecosystems' on the LEADER study mentioned elsewhere on the site : The Provision of Sustainable Toilets in Remote Rural Locations.
I attended the 2006 Finland Dry Toilet conference and my colleague David Shields attended the 2009 conference.
David presented a paper on my work with the MBA and the National Trust to establish an experimental toilet at Corrour bothy in the Lairig Ghru in the Cairngorms National Park. The paper can be found here in the book of abstracts of the conference :
http://huussi.net/tapahtumat/DT2009/pdf/Book_of_Abstracts.pdf
and further information about the Corrour bothy project can be found here :
http://www.compostloos.org.uk/
Living Water is a pioneering design company applying ecological principles to solve water and waste problems.
I would be very pleased to receive input from anyone interested in the work of this study, particularly those with experience of rural toilet provision. Please contact me at support@compostloos.org.uk
Thanks JC.
Ecological sanitation workshop at International Rural Network
Sandra Hogg recently posted a report on a workshop about Ecological Sanitation that she attended at the International Rural Network Forum event in India. Here's the link: http://www.ruralgateway.org.uk/en/node/1268
This is also where my comment about the project in the Cairngorms first featured.